Vince Vaughn is good at spinning nothing into something. His rapid-fire riffs pile up with sidebars and tangents. They move with such velocity that you almost forget the movie underneath them is a very standard romantic comedy.
He plays Gary, a Chicago tour guide who’d rather come home, kick back, and sink into video games than pitch in with the social upkeep his girlfriend Brooke (Jennifer Aniston) expects. Brooke is an art dealer who thinks a relationship should involve more than burping through dinner prep. Their romance collapses early. Neither of them moves out. They stay in the condo. Locked in a low-grade domestic war that doesn’t stop even after things get ugly.
The story gestures toward a will-they-won’t-they. What you end up watching most of the time is Vaughn running his mouth while Aniston volleys back with eye rolls and sharply timed retorts. Aniston isn’t exactly a live wire, but she’s also not yielding much either.
Peyton Reed keeps the direction deliberately plain. Almost TV-neutral, which puts nearly all the pressure on the actors to generate momentum themselves. And to their credit, they do. Vaughn thrives in that looseness. Aniston steadies it. The movie isn’t shaped to their energy as much as it gives them space to carry the scenes.
The supporting cast juices things further. John Michael Higgins, in particular, is hysterical as Vaughn’s manic brother-in-law, who drags his over-enthused a cappella friends into sing-along interventions meant to coax the couple back into line.
The digressions are often funny, but they don’t push things forward. What you’re really watching is the friction between the two leads. Vaughn talks in circles. Aniston digs in. The rest is just waiting.